How To Make the BEST Vanilla Extract

Learn how to make the BEST homemade vanilla extract with MORE FLAVOR than store-bought!  It will enhance your baking, it makes the perfect gifts, is super easy to make and only requires two ingredients!  Learning how to make vanilla extract seriously couldn’t be any easier!

You know a good vanilla extract when you unscrew the bottle and inhale.  Imitation and lower quality pure extracts just lack the same depth and combination of fruity and earthy notes in their aroma.  Nothing beats quality vanilla extract.  But top quality vanilla extracts are expensive.  Guess what?  You can make your own homemade vanilla extract that will taste BETTER than the best store-bought extracts!

Here’s what you’ll need:

• Vanilla Beans
• 80 proof alcohol
• Glass jars
• A funnel

We’ll discuss these in detail below.

Single Fold vs. Double Fold Vanilla Extract – What’s the Difference?

Single-fold vanilla extract is what most reputable manufacturers of good vanilla extract make.  In order to be considered commercial grade extract, single-fold extract is required to use 13 ounces of vanilla beans per gallon (or .8 ounces per cup) of vodka or whatever kind of alcohol is being used.

Double-fold vanilla extracts are what many professional bakers prefer to use because it provides a much stronger, more concentrated vanilla flavor that you can’t get simply by doubling the amount of vanilla extract you use.  It’s wonderfully potent and gives baked goods and desserts a much richer vanilla flavor.  Commercially sold double-fold vanilla extract is required to be made with with 23 ounces of beans per gallon of alcohol (or 1.5 ounces per cup).  And double-fold vanilla extract comes with an even bigger price tag than single-fold.

So the choice is yours depending on your needs.  You can either make single- or double-fold vanilla extract and either way you go it will be much cheaper than store-bought.  And it’s so easy to do! 

I like to make larger quantities to extract to allow them to age for at least a year before using it.

And you’ll probably want to go with a larger quantity anyway because this vanilla extract makes the perfect gift.  Seriously, who wouldn’t be happy to receive a bottle of this?  It makes the perfect hostess gift when you’re invited over somewhere, a great gift for your child’s teacher, a get-well-soon gift, or for any occasion you want to send the message “I’m thinking of you.”

What Kind of Alcohol is Best for Making Vanilla Extract?

You can use any alcohol as long as it is 80 proof.  The best and most popular choices are vodka, bourbon, brandy, or rum.

Vodka is the most versatile because it has a neutral flavor.  If you’re using vodka don’t worry about splurging for the expensive brands because it really doesn’t make a significant difference.  Go for a cheaper brand – it’s the quality of the vanilla beans that counts.

Which Vanilla Beans are Best for Making Vanilla Extract?

Madagascar Bourbon vanilla beans are the most popular and what I use by far the most.  Another option is Tahitian vanilla beans.  A third option is Mexican vanilla beans.  Each have their own subtle nuances.

• Madagascar Bourbon Vanilla – what most people associate with vanilla flavor.  Full, creamy, sweet and mellow flavor with long-lasting flavor tones.
• Tahitian Vanilla – floral aroma with cherry-like, licorice and caramel flavor tones.
• Mexican Vanilla – both sweet and woody flavor tones with spicy hint of cloves and nutmeg.

You can experience how the difference between the Madagascar and Mexican vanilla beans play out in our classic Pots de Creme and Mexican Pots de Creme recipes.

Depending on which beans you use can make your choice of Madagascar Bourbon Vanilla Extract, Tahitian Vanilla Extract or Mexican Vanilla Extract.  How fun is that?

What is the Difference Between Grade A and Grade B Vanilla Beans?

Whichever vanilla bean you go with, choose “Grade B” if it’s available.  Grade B is specifically meant for extracting and generally yields the most flavor.  Grade A vanilla beans are meant for cooking.  Grade B is typically also cheaper than grade A, which works out well.  But if you find a better deal on Grade A or Grade B isn’t available, Grade A will work great as well.

What Kind of Jars Should I Use For Vanilla Extract?  

Use glass jars.  I like to get a combination of 2 ounce jars and 4 ounce jars.  2 ounce jars are perfect for gift-giving and I use the 4 ounce jars for myself (or to give as gifts to people I REALLY like).

I also recommend using dark glass jars to keep light out which will help preserve the oils and flavor of the vanilla extract.  It’s a double layer of protection in addition to keeping the jars stored in a dark cupboard.

If you don’t have access to dark glass jars you can use clear jars but be sure to keep them stored in a dark place.

What’s the Best Way to Fill the Jars with the Vanilla Extract?

Use a small funnel.  It’s very inexpensive and it makes pouring a lot easier – and far less messy, eliminating any waste of your precious homemade vanilla extract.

How Many Vanilla Beans Should I Use Per Cup of Alcohol?

Most recipes for homemade vanilla extract call for 2-3 vanilla beans per cup of vodka.  We’re going to use 5 per cup.  This will result in a more potent vanilla extract that will make your baked goods and desserts soar.  That will also enable you to use less extract in a recipe to get just as much vanilla flavor without any alcohol flavor.

How To Make Vanilla Extract

Ready to learn how to make vanilla extract?  Let’s get started!

Slice the vanilla beans in half lengthwise.

See those luscious vanilla bean flecks inside?

Scrape those out with a knife and add them to the jar of vodka.

Scraping it out is optional because the flavors will distill into the vodka regardless, but I like the presence of the vanilla bean flecks that settle at the bottom of the bottles.

It makes it a dead giveaway that it’s the real stuff and just looks more authentic and higher quality.

Once you’ve sliced the beans and scraped out the flecks we’re ready to place everything in the vodka.

Use any glass jar with a fitted lid that you prefer.  I used my quart-sized canning jar this time.  Place the scraped out vanilla flecks and beans in the jar with the vodka and screw the lid on tightly.  Make sure the vanilla beans are submerged under the alcohol otherwise any exposed parts can become slimy and potentially ruin your extract.

That’s it.  Now your job is simply to give it a shake every now and then during the ripening process.  It will become very dark within just a few days.  Go ahead and take a sniff every now and then, it’s wonderful!

How Long Does Vanilla Extract Need to Age?

Aside from the quality of the vanilla beans themselves, the most important factor that determines the quality of your finished vanilla extract is how long you allow the vanilla extract to age.

While you can use it in as little as 8 weeks the flavor becomes vastly superior the longer it ages.  Optimally you should wait at least 6 months and for the best results wait 12 months.

I make a large batch every year and then use the previous year’s batch for my own use and for gifts.  12-month aged pure vanilla extract – it’s gold!   I’m currently using 24-month aged vanilla – it’s even better!

When the extract is ready pour it into the bottles.  You can use any size you like.

As mentioned earlier, I like to use the standard 2-ounce and 4-ounce jar sizes as gifts.

Place the funnel in the jars and pour in the extract, leaving a little headspace.

Should I Add the Vanilla Beans to the Jars of My Finished Extract?

Something I like to do is trim the vanilla beans to the height of the small bottles and add two pieces in the 2-ounce jars and 4 pieces in the 4-ounce jars.  That means the extract will continue to increase in flavor as it sits.

Plus it just looks neat for anyone you’re giving these jars to – it looks high quality and professional.

But you can also use those extracted vanilla beans for another delicious purpose….keep reading below…..

Can You Reuse Vanilla Beans?

Yes and no.  You can reuse them to make another batch of extract but keep in mind that they will have lost some of their potency and so the next batch will not be as strong.  What I’ll do if I’m reusing them is combine the “old” ones with “new” ones to make a new batch.

How To Reuse Vanilla Beans to Make Vanilla Sugar

My favorite way to use “used” vanilla beans is to make vanilla sugar.

Got some extracted beans left after dividing them up between the small bottles?  Don’t waste them – make vanilla sugar!

It’s so easy!  Just let the beans dry out for a few days until they’re totally dry and then place them in a container or ziploc bag of sugar.  Seal it shut and let it sit a few weeks, shaking it occasionally.

Discard the vanilla beans – your vanilla sugar is ready to use!

I hope you enjoyed this tutorial on making your own vanilla extract and hope you’ve been inspired to give it a go!

You’ll be absolutely thrilled with the results!

 

PIN ME!

For some more fun and delicious DIY recipes be sure to try our homemade Candied Ginger and Candied Orange Peel!